Pit Barrel Cooker vs Ugly Drum Smoker: Which One Reigns Supreme for BBQ Enthusiasts?

When it comes to backyard smoking, two contenders stand out: the Pit Barrel Cooker and the Ugly Drum Smoker. Both offer unique advantages and drawbacks, making the choice between them a matter of personal preference and specific needs. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the key differences between the Pit Barrel Cooker vs Ugly Drum Smoker, helping you make an informed decision for your next smoking adventure.

Design and Construction

Pit Barrel Cooker:

• Vertical design with a 19-gallon steel drum
• Single top vent with a built-in temperature gauge
• Three adjustable legs for stability

Ugly Drum Smoker:

• Horizontal design with a 55-gallon steel drum
• Side firebox with a separate charcoal chamber
• Multiple vents for airflow control

Cooking Capacity

Pit Barrel Cooker:

• Holds approximately 10-15 pounds of meat
• Suitable for small to medium-sized gatherings

Ugly Drum Smoker:

• Holds approximately 30-50 pounds of meat
• Ideal for large gatherings and catering events

Temperature Control

Pit Barrel Cooker:

• Indirect heat cooking with airflow controlled by the top vent
• Maintains a consistent temperature of around 225-250°F
• Not suitable for high-temperature cooking

Ugly Drum Smoker:

• Direct and indirect heat cooking with adjustable vents
• Can reach temperatures up to 350°F
• More versatile for different smoking styles

Fuel Efficiency

Pit Barrel Cooker:

• Requires approximately 10-15 charcoal briquettes per cook
• Very fuel-efficient due to its vertical design

Ugly Drum Smoker:

• Requires more charcoal, typically 20-30 briquettes per cook
• Less fuel-efficient than the Pit Barrel Cooker

Ease of Use

Pit Barrel Cooker:

• Simple design makes it easy to set up and use
• Hanging hooks allow for easy meat placement
• Requires minimal maintenance

Ugly Drum Smoker:

• More complex design, requiring some assembly
• Can be more challenging to operate, especially for beginners
• Requires regular cleaning and maintenance

Portability

Pit Barrel Cooker:

• Compact and lightweight, weighing around 50 pounds
• Easy to transport and store

Ugly Drum Smoker:

• Bulky and heavy, weighing around 200 pounds
• Not as portable as the Pit Barrel Cooker

Price

Pit Barrel Cooker:

• Typically ranges from $200 to $300
• More affordable option

Ugly Drum Smoker:

• Typically ranges from $300 to $500
• More expensive option

Which One is Right for You?

The best choice between a Pit Barrel Cooker and an Ugly Drum Smoker depends on your specific needs and preferences.
Pit Barrel Cooker is ideal for:

• Small to medium-sized gatherings
• Simple and easy smoking
• Fuel efficiency
• Portability

Ugly Drum Smoker is ideal for:

• Large gatherings
• Versatile cooking options
• High-temperature smoking
• Durability

Conclusion: The Ultimate Verdict

Both the Pit Barrel Cooker and the Ugly Drum Smoker are excellent choices for backyard smoking enthusiasts. The Pit Barrel Cooker offers simplicity, fuel efficiency, and portability, while the Ugly Drum Smoker provides versatility, capacity, and durability. Ultimately, the best choice for you will depend on your individual requirements and budget.

FAQ

Q: Which smoker is easier to use?
A: The Pit Barrel Cooker is generally considered easier to use due to its simple design and hanging hooks.
Q: Which smoker produces better-tasting food?
A: Both smokers can produce excellent-tasting food, but the flavor will depend on the type of meat, seasonings, and smoking technique used.
Q: Which smoker is more durable?
A: The Ugly Drum Smoker is typically more durable due to its larger size and heavier construction.
Q: Which smoker is more versatile?
A: The Ugly Drum Smoker is more versatile as it allows for both direct and indirect heat cooking, as well as higher temperatures.
Q: Which smoker is more expensive?
A: The Ugly Drum Smoker is generally more expensive than the Pit Barrel Cooker.