Tomato Sauce Vs Soup: Which One Is Right For You?

Tomato sauce. Tomato soup.

Why trust me?

I'm an experienced food writer and passionate cook. My website,, features accessible, informative, and engaging content with quality recipes and articles that are thoroughly researched and enjoyable to read. You can trust my expertise with 8 years of experience in the field. Learn more about me and my work on this website, and check out my featured articles on TastingTable, Mashed, and 5-Minute Crafts. Read more about me HERE.

You might think these are the same thing, but they’re not!

This will probably surprise you, since they both contain tomatoes as well as other ingredients that appear in both dishes.

However, there are also some pretty important differences between tomato sauce and tomato soup, including their consistency and how they’re often used.

In this article we’ll cover the similarities and differences between tomato sauce and tomato soup so you’ll be able to confidently choose the right ingredient to make your next meal a success.

What is special about tomato sauce?

[amazon fields=”B07TSCWN1P” value=”thumb” image=”1″ image_size=”large” image_align=”center”]

Tomato sauce is a thick and smooth sauce made from tomatoes.

It contains no dairy products, such as butter or cream.

Tomato sauce has a tangy taste and can be used to add flavor to many dishes.

Tomato soup is also made using tomatoes, but it’s not as thick or smooth as tomato sauce—it’s more like a broth in consistency (or “broth” if you’re British).

In addition to the main ingredient being tomatoes, there are other ingredients in tomato soup that give it this different texture and flavor profile compared with tomato sauce: some people add milk or chicken broth when making soup; others add seasonings such as basil leaves or thyme sprigs.

What is special about tomato soup?

[amazon fields=”B09NCS1X8K” value=”thumb” image=”1″ image_size=”large” image_align=”center”]

But what is special about tomato soup?

  • It’s made from tomatoes.
  • This might seem obvious, but there are many different types of soups that can be considered a “tomato” soup.
  • For example, some people add other ingredients such as peppers or basil to their tomato soups for flavor.
  • Others like to add milk or cream to make them smoother and creamier.
  • However, if you just have tomatoes as the only ingredient in your soup, then technically it qualifies as tomato soup!
  • It’s usually served hot.
  • Tomato soup is typically served at room temperature or warmed up (like other soups), which makes it easier to eat than something like ice cream—but if you’re feeling adventurous one day and want to try eating a bowl of cold tomato soup after coming home from work on a hot summer day…
  • go ahead!
  • You might find out that it tastes even better than normal warm tomato soup does!
  • It may be made from fresh tomatoes or canned tomatoes (or both!).
  • Some people prefer using fresh tomatoes when making homemade tomato paste; others prefer using canned because they don’t have time/don’t feel like waiting around while all those fresh ones cook down on their own before they’re ready for use here at home.”

Does tomato soup taste like tomato sauce?

So what does tomato soup taste like?

Well, it depends on the recipe.

But generally speaking, all of these ingredients are thickened with a roux (a mixture of butter and flour) and cooked with liquid to create a concentrated sauce.

And that’s where you’ll notice the differences between tomato soup and tomato sauce: while they both contain tomatoes as their base ingredient, they have different consistencies.

Tomato soup is usually thicker than tomato sauce because it contains much more water than its cousin.

This can range anywhere from being soupy to liquidy depending on how long you cook it for (and what kind of device you use).

It also means that while homemade tomato sauce may be considered more “authentic” by some people who prefer thicker sauces in general, most brands available at grocery stores will have added thickeners such as cornstarch or flour which make them resemble more traditional soups in terms of consistency.

Tomato sauce vs tomato soup: What’s the similarity?

Tomato soup and tomato sauce are both made from tomatoes.

All the difference in the world!

But what is it?

Tomato soup is thicker, creamier and served hot.

Its consistency can vary from thin to thick (depending on how much flour or cornstarch is added).

It’s often served as a first course at dinner, but also makes for an attractive side dish when served with grilled cheese sandwiches or burgers.

In contrast, tomato sauce has less liquid than its cousin and doesn’t contain any added thickeners—it’s just puree of raw tomatoes cooked down until it reaches your desired thickness.

This means that you only need to cook your sauce for 10-15 minutes before serving—you don’t need to reheat it later like you would with soup!

Tomato sauce goes great with pasta dishes like spaghetti Bolognese or lasagna because of its simplicity and versatility; however if you prefer something heartier then why not try making meatballs in tomato sauce instead?

Tomato sauce vs tomato soup: What’s the difference?

[amazon fields=”B07TSCWN1P” value=”title”][amazon fields=”B09NCS1X8K” value=”title”]
[amazon fields=”B07TSCWN1P” value=”thumb”][amazon fields=”B09NCS1X8K” value=”thumb”]
[amazon fields=”B07TSCWN1P” value=”button”][amazon fields=”B09NCS1X8K” value=”button”]

Tomato soup and tomato sauce are both made of tomatoes, but that’s about where their similarities end.

Tomato soup is a thickened liquid in which tomatoes are cooked, while tomato sauce is uncooked and contains more tomato pulp than it does liquid.

Tomato soup is typically made with a roux (flour cooked in oil), whereas tomato sauce often has no flour at all.

The difference between the two also lies in how they’re used: while tomato soups are often served as soups or bases for other soups, sauces are usually used as an accompaniment to pasta or pizza—or anything else on which you’d like some extra flavor.

If you want something light enough to eat with your lunchtime sandwich or burger but want to bring some extra color and flavor along with it, reach for the sauce!

Can tomato soup be used in place of tomato sauce?

Can tomato soup be used in place of tomato sauce?

It’s a good question, and one that can be answered with a definitive “no.” While some people may find this disappointing, it is important to remember that there are many things in life that cannot be substituted for each other.

For example: you can’t substitute a chocolate bar for an apple.

Or even worse (or better?), you can’t substitute Mariah Carey’s Glitter album for an actual glitter cone (a cone made out of glitter).

But enough about those things!

So why are we talking about them?

Because they’re all examples of what happens when you try to substitute something without thinking through the consequences.


Tomato sauce is used as a condiment, or topping, for food.

Tomato soup, on the other hand, is a dish in its own right and can also be used as an ingredient in another recipe.

The two tomato products are similar in that they both contain tomatoes, but they have enough differences that you can’t really use one as a substitute for the other without ruining your dish!