What To Know
- Both brands offer a wide range of smokers, but their flagship models, the Char-Griller 980 and Masterbuilt 800, are the crème de la crème.
- It provides ample cooking space and a durable construction at a reasonable price.
- It is ideal for those who want a convenient and reliable smoker with a vertical design that allows for versatile cooking options.
When it comes to backyard smoking, two names stand out: Char-Griller and Masterbuilt. Both brands offer a wide range of smokers, but their flagship models, the Char-Griller 980 and Masterbuilt 800, are the crème de la crème. So, which one is the better choice? Let’s dive into a comprehensive comparison to find out.
Design and Construction
Char-Griller 980:
- 18-gauge steel construction
- Powder-coated finish for durability
- Offset firebox with a water pan for moisture control
- Two porcelain-coated grates provide ample cooking space
Masterbuilt 800:
- 24-gauge steel construction
- Painted finish
- Vertical smoking cabinet with a side firebox
- Four chrome-plated smoking racks offer multiple cooking levels
Cooking Area and Capacity
Char-Griller 980:
- 980 square inches of total cooking area
- 780 square inches of primary cooking grate
- 200 square inches of warming rack
Masterbuilt 800:
- 800 square inches of total cooking area
- 725 square inches of primary cooking grate
- 75 square inches of warming rack
Fuel Type and Temperature Control
Char-Griller 980:
- Charcoal fuel
- Manual temperature control via air vents
- Temperature range of 225°F to 700°F
Masterbuilt 800:
- Propane or wood chips
- Digital temperature control with an LCD display
- Temperature range of 150°F to 400°F
Features and Accessories
Char-Griller 980:
- Offset firebox allows for indirect heat cooking
- Water pan provides moisture and prevents flare-ups
- Fold-down side shelves for convenience
Masterbuilt 800:
- Side firebox with a loading door for easy fuel access
- Digital temperature control for precise cooking
- Built-in meat probe for temperature monitoring
Performance and Versatility
Char-Griller 980:
- Excellent for low-and-slow smoking and grilling
- Charcoal fuel imparts a smoky flavor to food
- Requires manual temperature control, which can be challenging
Masterbuilt 800:
- Consistent and easy-to-control temperatures
- Propane fuel is convenient and eliminates the need for charcoal
- Vertical design allows for smoking multiple items simultaneously
Price and Value
Char-Griller 980:
- Typically priced between $400-$500
- Offers a great value for the price
Masterbuilt 800:
- Typically priced between $600-$700
- Provides a premium experience with advanced features
The Verdict: Which Smoker is the Clear Winner?
Both the Char-Griller 980 and Masterbuilt 800 are exceptional smokers that offer distinct advantages. The Char-Griller 980 is an excellent choice for those who prefer the traditional charcoal flavor and manual temperature control. It provides ample cooking space and a durable construction at a reasonable price.
On the other hand, the Masterbuilt 800 shines with its advanced features, precise temperature control, and ease of use. It is ideal for those who want a convenient and reliable smoker with a vertical design that allows for versatile cooking options.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you value charcoal flavor, durability, and affordability, the Char-Griller 980 is the way to go. If you prioritize convenience, precise temperature control, and a wide range of features, the Masterbuilt 800 is the perfect choice.
Popular Questions
1. Which smoker is better for beginners?
The Masterbuilt 800 is easier to use due to its digital temperature control and convenient fuel loading.
2. Which smoker produces a smokier flavor?
The Char-Griller 980, due to its charcoal fuel, imparts a more intense smoky flavor to food.
3. Which smoker is more versatile?
The Masterbuilt 800 allows for multiple cooking levels and can accommodate various smoking methods, including hot and cold smoking.
4. Which smoker is more durable?
Both smokers are made of sturdy steel, but the Char-Griller 980 has a thicker 18-gauge construction.
5. Which smoker has a better warranty?
The Masterbuilt 800 comes with a 5-year warranty, while the Char-Griller 980 has a 3-year warranty.
