Food Guide

10 Easy Ways to Transform Bland Potato Salad into a Deliciously Flavorful Dish!

Potato salad is a classic dish, but it can also be bland sometimes.

Don’t worry!

This guide will help you make the most flavorful and delicious potato salad, even if your potatoes are boring and done cooking.

What are some common mistakes when making potato salad?

While potato salad is a delicious, simple dish to make, it can be easy to make mistakes when you’re in the kitchen.

Here are some common mistakes that may turn your potato salad bland:

  • Not cooking potatoes until soft enough: Potatoes should be cooked until they are soft in the center.

If you’re making a cold potato salad, cook your potatoes ahead of time and let them cool before adding them to your recipe.

  • Overcooking potatoes: Potatoes should be cooked until they are soft but not mushy.

Overcooked potatoes will ruin not only the texture but also the flavor.

  • Soggy potato salad: Potato salad should be creamy, not soggy.

Make sure the potatoes are drained well before adding them to your recipe.

If you’re using a mayonnaise-based dressing, make sure it’s thick enough that it doesn’t just run off the potatoes when tossed together.

And it is best to add the dressing right before serving.

  • Too heavy: Potato salad should be light and creamy, not heavy.

It will be easy to eat if your potato salad is thick enough and thick enough.

You don’t want to add so much that you can’t taste the potatoes anymore.

Bland potato salads are not appealing either, so be careful while seasoning this dish.

Why does my potato salad taste so bland?

It’s common for potato salad to be a little bland, but it should always be flavorless.

Here are some reasons why your potato salad might taste so bland:

  • The potatoes weren’t cooked in salted water beforehand: A good rule of thumb is to cook your potatoes in water with a bit of salt before using them for the salad.

This way, the potatoes will absorb moisture and flavor from the boiling water.

  • You didn’t season enough before serving (or didn’t season at all!).

Remember that even if you’re using fresh herbs or vegetables—like tomatoes or cucumbers—they can still lose their flavor over time as they sit around waiting for people to eat them up at picnics or potlucks.

Therefore, to get rid of bland potato salad, keep your eyes while boiling potatoes next time.

How do you spice up your bland potato salad?

To make an uninspired potato salad flavorful, you can follow one of these tips:

Add salt

Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sea Salt, Fine Ground, 16 Ounce

If your potato salad is bland, adding salt is one of the easiest ways to spice it up.

Salt is a flavor enhancer, and it can make food taste better even if it doesn’t have much flavor at all.

The amount of salt you add depends on personal preference and the amount of flavor in your potatoes (some types have more).

But if you’re unsure, start with just 1/4 teaspoon per half cup of potatoes—and then add more until the flavor suits you!

Add spices and herbs

Frontier Co-op Herbes De Provence, 0.85 Ounce Bottle, Kosher,...

You can also add black pepper, paprika, and cumin t doctor up your bland salad.

If you want to get more creative, try adding coriander and chives as well.

You can even add rosemary, thyme, and sage for an earthy flavor.

Make sure you taste all of them before mixing them in so that you avoid accidentally adding too much heat.

Add a splash of vinegar

Amazon Brand - Happy Belly White Distilled Vinegar, Kosher, 16 Fl Oz...

The acidity in the vinegar will help balance out the flavors and bring out some of the natural sweetness that’s hiding in your potatoes.

If you’re wondering how much vinegar to add, it depends on your taste preferences and how acidic your potato salad already is.

If you find that it’s too tart, try adding more potatoes or vegetables until you’re satisfied with the flavor balance.

In case there is no vinegar in your kitchen or local grocery store, feel free to substitute it with apple cider vinegar or balsamic vinegar.

Add celery seed

Celery Seed Whole – 16 oz

Celery seed is an excellent option if you’re looking for an alternative to dill.

Celery seed has a pungent, distinct flavor that can be used in many different dishes.

Instead of using dill as your primary herb, try adding a few tablespoons of celery seed to your potato salad recipe.

Celery seeds will give your potato salad a nice, crunchy texture and a fresh flavor.

Try mixing it with some paprika or mustard powder for extra depth of flavor.

Add mayo

Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise, 30 Ounce Jar

Mayonnaise is a great way to add flavor and creaminess to bland potato salad.

It’s hard to go wrong with mayo because it has so many uses in the kitchen (a classic example being deviled eggs).

You can buy mayo ready-made at the store—but if you like making things from scratch, several recipes are available online.

Add mustard

Heinz 100% Natural Spicy Brown Mustard (14 oz Bottle)

Mustard is a wonderful addition to potato salad.

This is because mustard has a strong and pungent flavor, especially when it’s enhanced with vinegar and horseradish.

The South has long used mustard as a condiment for meats, poultry, and fish.

But did you know that Southern cooks are also big fans of adding mustard to their potato salads?


If you’re tired of bland potato salad and want to spice it up a little, try adding different ingredients and flavors.

For example, you can use garlic to flavor your salad or add some herbs like rosemary or thyme.

You could also replace the mayonnaise with another type of dressing, such as balsamic vinegar or olive oil.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. When you purchase an item from Amazon through one of my links, I receive a small commission at no added cost. This helps support the site!

Emily W.

Emily Wong is an Asian-American food writer the founder of With nearly 8 years of experience, she has a passion for making cooking accessible to everyone and sharing her personal experiences with food. Emily's vision for is to create a community of food lovers who are passionate about cooking, eating, and sharing their experiences with others. Read my story
Back to top button