What To Know
- The Members Mark grill comes with a side burner for cooking sauces or side dishes, while the Weber grill has a built-in igniter for easy startup.
- Members Mark offers a 10-year warranty on the burners and cooking grate, while Weber offers a 10-year warranty on the burners, 5-year warranty on the cooking grate, and 2-year warranty on the other components.
- While the Members Mark grill offers a larger grilling surface, Sear Zone burner, and lower price point, the Weber grill has convenient features, a Flavorizer system, and a more premium build.
When it comes to backyard grilling, two names reign supreme: Members Mark Pro Series and Weber. Both brands offer a range of high-quality gas grills, but which one is the right choice for your needs? In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll pit the Members Mark Pro Series 4 Burner Gas Grill against the Weber Genesis II E-435 to help you make an informed decision.
Features and Specifications
Size and Capacity
The Members Mark Pro Series grill has a larger grilling surface area (662 sq. in.) than the Weber Genesis II (620 sq. in.), providing ample space for grilling multiple items simultaneously. However, the Weber grill is slightly taller and wider, offering more vertical space for bulky items like roasts or whole chickens.
Burners and Heat Distribution
Both grills feature four stainless steel burners, but the Members Mark has a slightly higher total BTU output (60,000 vs. 57,000). The Members Mark also boasts a unique “Sear Zone” burner that provides intense heat for searing steaks or vegetables.
Cooking System
The Members Mark grill utilizes a porcelain-enameled cast iron cooking grate, while the Weber has stainless steel Flavorizer bars. Both systems provide excellent heat retention and even cooking. The Weber grill additionally features a “Flavorizer” system that vaporizes juices and adds smoky flavor to the food.
Convenience Features
The Members Mark grill comes with a side burner for cooking sauces or side dishes, while the Weber grill has a built-in igniter for easy startup. Both grills have convenient folding side tables for additional workspace.
Performance and Durability
Grilling Performance
Both the Members Mark and Weber grills deliver exceptional grilling performance. The high BTU output and even heat distribution ensure thorough cooking and consistent results. The Sear Zone burner on the Members Mark grill is particularly effective for searing meat.
Durability
Both grills are constructed from durable materials, including stainless steel and aluminum. The Members Mark grill features a thicker gauge steel body, which may provide greater longevity. The Weber grill, on the other hand, has a porcelain-enameled finish that protects against rust and corrosion.
Price and Value
The Members Mark Pro Series 4 Burner Gas Grill is typically priced lower than the Weber Genesis II E-435. However, it’s important to consider the features and performance of each grill when evaluating the value. The Weber grill offers additional convenience features, such as the built-in igniter and Flavorizer system, which may justify its higher price point for some buyers.
Warranty and Customer Support
Both Members Mark and Weber provide comprehensive warranties on their grills. Members Mark offers a 10-year warranty on the burners and cooking grate, while Weber offers a 10-year warranty on the burners, 5-year warranty on the cooking grate, and 2-year warranty on the other components. Both brands have a reputation for excellent customer support.
Which Grill is Right for You?
The choice between the Members Mark Pro Series 4 Burner Gas Grill and the Weber Genesis II E-435 ultimately depends on your individual needs and preferences.
If you prioritize:
- Larger grilling surface area: Members Mark Pro Series
- Intense searing capabilities: Members Mark Pro Series
- Lower price point: Members Mark Pro Series
If you prioritize:
- Convenience features (side burner, igniter): Weber Genesis II
- Flavorizer system for smoky flavor: Weber Genesis II
- Premium materials and finish: Weber Genesis II
Verdict: A Close Contender
Both the Members Mark Pro Series 4 Burner Gas Grill and the Weber Genesis II E-435 are excellent choices for backyard grilling. While the Members Mark grill offers a larger grilling surface, Sear Zone burner, and lower price point, the Weber grill has convenient features, a Flavorizer system, and a more premium build. Ultimately, the best grill for you will depend on your specific grilling needs and budget.
Common Questions and Answers
1. Which grill has a longer warranty?
Both Members Mark and Weber offer 10-year warranties on the burners.
2. Does the Weber grill come with a side burner?
No, the Weber Genesis II E-435 does not come with a side burner.
3. Which grill is easier to clean?
Both grills have porcelain-enameled cooking surfaces that are relatively easy to clean.
4. Can I use both grills for indirect cooking?
Yes, both grills can be used for indirect cooking by turning off the burners on one side and grilling over the indirect heat.
5. Which grill is better for large gatherings?
The Members Mark Pro Series grill has a larger grilling surface area and is better suited for large gatherings.
