Cooked Beef Roast Smells Like Fish: Is It Normal For Beef Roast To Smell Like Fish After Cooking?

cooked beef roast smells like fish

Cooking a beef roast cut can be intimidating the first time.

Why trust me?

I'm an experienced food writer and passionate cook. My website,, features accessible, informative, and engaging content with quality recipes and articles that are thoroughly researched and enjoyable to read. You can trust my expertise with 8 years of experience in the field. Learn more about me and my work on this website, and check out my featured articles on TastingTable, Mashed, and 5-Minute Crafts. Read more about me HERE.

You might be frustrated if your expensive cut of beef roast turns out to smell like fish.

So where does this smell come from and how can you get rid of it?

Let’s unravel all these things in this post.

Why does my cooked beef roast smell like fish?

Have you ever cooked a beef roast and then noticed that it smells like fish?

Beef should never smell like anything rather than beef, but sometimes it does.

Below are some reasons that can explain the fishy smell in your cooked beef roast.

Beef roast has been placed next to fish in the freezer without being carefully covered 

If you buy a cooked beef roast cut with an unclear origin, it might be produced from a sick cow.

Moreover, the cooked beef roast, if improperly stored, can be rotten over time and packed with a gross smell like fish.

Beef roast is cooked in excess oil that was used to cook fish

When it comes to the rotten egg smell, one of the main culprits is the bacteria called Salmonella.

Salmonella releases a gas that smells like sulfur, or more specifically, rotten fish.

This type of bacteria exists at a certain temperature and if you don’t cook your cooked beef roast properly, you cannot kill the Salmonella and the rotten egg smell will still be around your meat cut.

Grass-fed tends to smell and taste more fishy due to the higher omega-3 content

Is it safe to eat cooked beef roast that smells like fish?

[amazon fields=”B01LXS7YAM” value=”thumb” image=”1″ image_size=”large” image_align=”center”]

[amazon fields=”B01LXS7YAM” value=”button”]

The odor of something doesn’t usually mean anything bad until you taste it, but if it smells pungently and unpleasantly, you should still be on the lookout for any other signs of spoilage, such as an off-putting texture or mottled color on the cooked beef roast.

If there are no other indicators of spoilage, then go ahead and cook up that cooked beef roast.

Otherwise, toss it away and grab another cooked beef roast cut from your local butcher shop for your recipe.

How to get rid of the eggy smell from the cooked beef roast?

cooked beef roast cuts are definitely not a cheap option of meat, especially if you opt for a high-quality cut like tenderloin roast or ribeye roast.

Therefore, nobody wants to experiment with a cooked beef roast that smells bad like rotten fish.

So how to get rid of this problem?

Let’s take a closer look at the following suggestions:

Cook the cooked beef roast at the right temperature as the recipe calls for

Salmonella bacteria, which often causes the rotten egg smell in your cooked beef roast, can be killed at high temperatures.

Therefore, you should refer to a reliable recipe on the Internet (like from a famous chef or food blogger) to cook your cooked beef roast at a proper temperature so that no bad odor from any bacteria can survive.

Wash the cooked beef roast cut thoroughly and let the smell air out

[amazon fields=”B07985NMQD” value=”thumb” image=”1″ image_size=”large” image_align=”center”]

[amazon fields=”B07985NMQD” value=”button”]

You can also try washing your cooked beef roast thoroughly with salt and vinegar to take the rotten egg scent away.

Salt and vinegar have long been used for cooking, as well as cleaning.

These ingredients are very inexpensive and available in any grocery store or supermarket across the country.

Don’t forget to rinse the cooked beef roast again with plain water to remove any excess flavor from salt or vinegar.

After that, let your cooked beef roast pat dry at room temperature and the smell can air out during that time.

Buy a fresh cut of cooked beef roast from a reputable store and store it properly

[amazon fields=”B07BSB87FL” value=”thumb” image=”1″ image_size=”large” image_align=”center”]

[amazon fields=”B07BSB87FL” value=”button”]

If you want to avoid the rotten egg smell in your cooked beef roast from the beginning, it is best to opt for a high-quality cut of the cooked beef roast when you go shopping.

Look for a fresh cut instead of a frozen cut of cooked beef roast without any sign of spoilage from a reputable butcher shop.

When bringing it home, check the package and transfer it to another vacuum-sealed package if necessary before storing it in the freezer for later use.

Anyway, it is still recommended to cook it right away for the best result.

The bottom line

The smell of a beef roast cut cooking is often the first indication that it’s not or going to be as delicious as you hoped.

When your expensive cut of meat smells like fish, there are some ways to salvage it or prevent this fishy odor from developing in your beef roast dish.

Here we have unraveled all the common wonders about cooked beef roast that smells like fish so that next time you make a great dish from this cut, everyone will enjoy it.