You’ll Never Guess Which Macaroni Salad Is The Winner In This Amish Vs Original Showdown!

amish vs original macaroni salad

If you’re anything like me, you love a good macaroni salad. There’s something about the combination of tender noodles, crisp vegetables, and tangy dressing that just hits the spot. But did you know that there are two main versions of this classic side dish?

Why trust me?

I'm an experienced food writer and passionate cook. My website,, features accessible, informative, and engaging content with quality recipes and articles that are thoroughly researched and enjoyable to read. You can trust my expertise with 8 years of experience in the field. Learn more about me and my work on this website, and check out my featured articles on TastingTable, Mashed, and 5-Minute Crafts. Read more about me HERE.

That’s right – today, we’re going to compare the classic macaroni salad to the Amish version, highlighting their differences, similarities, and which one is tastier. So get ready to take a deep dive into the world of macaroni salad!

CriteriaClassic Macaroni SaladAmish Macaroni Salad
DressingMayonnaise-based with mustard, vinegar, and sugarMayonnaise-based with yellow mustard and apple cider vinegar
Flavor ProfileCreamy and comfortingTangy and flavorful
Regional PopularityPopular throughout the United StatesMost popular in the Midwest, especially in Pennsylvania Dutch country

Macaroni Salad

Let’s start with the basics – what exactly is macaroni salad? Essentially, it’s a side dish made from cooked macaroni noodles mixed with various ingredients, such as chopped vegetables, hard-boiled eggs, and a creamy dressing. The dish is typically served chilled and is a staple at picnics, potlucks, and backyard barbecues.

The history of macaroni salad can be traced back to the early 1900s when it became popular in the United States. It’s thought that the dish may have originated from Italian pasta salads, but it quickly evolved into its unique creation. Today, there are countless variations of macaroni salad, with different regions and families putting their spin on the classic recipe.

When it comes to the ingredients used in a classic macaroni salad, there are a few staples that you’ll usually find: macaroni noodles, mayonnaise, celery, onion, and sometimes carrots. The dressing is typically a mixture of mayo, vinegar, and sugar, although some people prefer to add mustard or sour cream for an extra kick. And, of course, you can’t forget the hard-boiled eggs – they add a creamy texture and extra protein to the dish.

Pros of classic macaroni salad? It’s creamy, comforting, and easy to make. Plus, it’s a great way to get some veggies and protein. Cons? It can be a bit heavy and may not be the healthiest option out there.

Amish Macaroni Salad

Now, let’s move on to the Amish version of macaroni salad. This version is known for being tangier and more flavorful than the classic version, thanks to a few key ingredients. Amish macaroni salad is typically made with macaroni noodles, hard-boiled eggs, dill pickles, celery, onion, and a dressing made from mayonnaise, yellow mustard, and apple cider vinegar.

The history of Amish macaroni salad is a bit harder to trace, but it’s thought that the recipe originated from the Amish community in Pennsylvania. It quickly became a favorite among locals and has since spread throughout the country.

Pros of Amish macaroni salad? It’s tangy, flavorful, and has a nice crunch, thanks to the pickles and celery. However, some people may find it too acidic or sour, depending on their taste preferences.

Differences between Classic and Amish Macaroni Salad

Now that we’ve covered the basics of each type of macaroni salad, let’s talk about their differences.


One of the main things that set them apart is the texture – classic macaroni salad is creamier, while Amish macaroni salad is tangier and has more of a bite.


The ingredients used are also quite different. Classic macaroni salad typically includes celery, onion, and sometimes carrots, while Amish macaroni salad includes hard-boiled eggs and dill pickles. And, of course, the dressing is different – classic macaroni salad is typically dressed with mayonnaise, vinegar, and sugar. In contrast, the Amish macaroni salad has a dressing made from mayonnaise, yellow mustard, and apple cider vinegar.

Regional popularity

Another key difference is the region where each dish is most popular. Classic macaroni salad is a staple at picnics and barbecues throughout the United States, while Amish macaroni salad is most popular in the Midwest, especially in Pennsylvania, a Dutch country.

Which one is tastier?

As you can see, while both versions of macaroni salad are delicious in their own right, there are some key differences in terms of flavor and preparation. But which one is tastier? Well, that’s really up to personal preference. Classic macaroni salad is probably your best bet if you’re a fan of creamy, comforting dishes. But if you’re someone who loves tangy, flavorful foods, Amish macaroni salad might be more your speed. So next time you’re in the mood for some macaroni salad, why not try both and see which one you prefer?


  • What other variations of macaroni salad are there? There are countless variations of macaroni salad out there! Some people like to add in extras like bacon, olives, or even shrimp.
  • Can I make a healthier version of macaroni salad? Absolutely! Try using a Greek yogurt-based dressing instead of mayonnaise, and load up on extra veggies like bell peppers and cherry tomatoes.
  • Is macaroni salad safe to eat at a picnic or barbecue? It’s important to be mindful of food safety when eating any dish containing mayonnaise or other dairy-based dressings. Keep the dish chilled, and don’t leave it in the sun for too long.

Overall, whether you prefer classic macaroni salad or Amish macaroni salad, there’s no denying that this classic side dish is a crowd-pleaser. So the next time you’re planning a picnic or barbecue, why not whip up a big batch of your favorite version and see which one your friends and family prefer?