Food Guide

You Won’t Believe What Happens When You Combine Beef Stew and Tomatoes – Try This Delicious Dish Now!

Winter is coming and with it the cold days that make you crave a big pot of hot beef stew.

However, many people have complained that their beef stews taste like tomatoes, which makes them feel unpleasant when enjoying this winter dish.

Don’t worry, this article will help you understand why your beef stew gets the tomato taste and how to get rid of it.

Let’s check it out!

Why does my beef stew taste like tomatoes?

Fresh Brand – Beef Stew Meat, USDA Choice, Boneless, 1 lb

Beef stew has a beefy and tangy taste from the ingredients.

But when it tastes a bit or too sour, like tomatoes, there must be something wrong.

Here we are going to tell you some possible reasons that can make your beef stew taste like tomatoes:

You have used too many tomatoes in the recipe

If your beef stew tastes like tomatoes, chances are you have used a lot of tomatoes more than what the recipe calls for.

Tomato sauce or paste is one of the key ingredients to complete a hearty beef stew.

But if you accidentally add a lot of tomato sauce/paste to your beef stew, the resulting dish will taste more like a tomato soup rather than a beef stew.

One ingredient might be spoiled

The second thing you can think about when your beef stew has a tomato-like taste is that a somewhat ingredient has been spoiled.

Since tomatoes have a sour flavor, and so does spoiled food.

Whether it is meat or vegetables, when being spoiled, they can release a sour taste to your stew.

Is it safe to eat beef stew that tastes like tomatoes?

It actually depends on the reason that causes the tomato-like taste in your beef stew.

If it is because you add a lot of tomatoes to your dish, your beef stew will be safe to consume.

However, the high acidity in your stew can make the dish less delicious.

Otherwise, if your beef stew has a sour taste due to a spoiled ingredient, then it is not safe anymore for consumption.

In this case, chances are your stew will also come with another sign of spoilage like a slushy texture or even mold on the surface.

Eating beef stew that is already spoiled can make you throw up, or get other symptoms of foodborne illnesses.

How to get rid of the tomato taste from beef stew?

Again, it is dependable to the reason that causes the tomato taste in your beef stew to opt for the most proper way to get rid of this problem:

Add a sweetener like sugar or syrup

Torino Sugar white 1/50Lbs bag Granulated-White-Pure Cane Crystal...

If your beef stew ends up with a too sour taste because you add too many tomatoes to the pot, you can use a sweetener to balance the sour taste.

Some common sweeteners are sugar, syrup, or even honey.

They add sweetness to your dish to balance the sourness of tomatoes.

However, remember to add a little by little and give your stew a check to avoid making it too sweet.

Add more carrots or caramelized onions

365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Carrots, 1 lb Bag

If you don’t want to use common sweeteners that have been listed above, try using vegetables with a sweet taste.

Carrots and onions will be ideal in this case.

These ingredients are also what is typically used in a classic beef stew recipe.

Use low-acid tomatoes

You can also use low-acid tomatoes to prevent your dish from being too sour.

There are different varieties of low-acid tomatoes on the market, from the tomatoes to their products.

Make sure to read the information on the package carefully or ask for help from the seller to opt for the right product.

Buy fresh ingredients from a reputable store and use them as soon as possible

To get rid of the sour taste like tomatoes from spoiled ingredients, just shop for fresh and high-quality ingredients initially.

You can look for them in a reputable and famous supermarket in the country or in your neighborhood.

Just use these fresh elements as soon as possible instead of storing them for too long in the fridge or freezer to ensure the freshness and deliciousness of your dish.

The bottom line

In conclusion, the key to making a delicious and flavorful pot of beef stew is the right proportion of ingredients.

If your beef stew ends up with a tomato-like taste, chances are you have used a lot of tomatoes more than what the recipe calls for, or there is a problem with one of the ingredients.

With our aforementioned ways to get rid of the tomato taste in your beef stew, hopefully, your beef stew will never taste like tomatoes anymore, but the rich and hearty taste that it is supposed to be.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. When you purchase an item from Amazon through one of my links, I receive a small commission at no added cost. This helps support the site!

Emily W.

Emily Wong is an Asian-American food writer the founder of With nearly 8 years of experience, she has a passion for making cooking accessible to everyone and sharing her personal experiences with food. Emily's vision for is to create a community of food lovers who are passionate about cooking, eating, and sharing their experiences with others. Read my story
Back to top button