Food Guide

Who Will Win? Amish Potato Salad vs. Regular Potato Salad – Find Out Now!

When you think of potato salad, what comes to mind?

It will be a dish that is creamy, tangy, and delicious.

But did you know that there are different types of potato salad?

In this blog post, we will be comparing Amish potato salad and regular potato salad.

While both salads are made with potatoes and may include similar ingredients, there are some distinct differences between the two.

Let’s read on to find out.

What is special about amish potato salad?

Reser's Deviled Egg Potato Salad, 16 Oz

Check Current Price

The Amish are famously private people, but one of their traditional dishes is now gaining popularity outside their community.

First, instead of the usual mayo-based salads, it is traditionally made with boiled red potatoes until they are very soft, which makes for a creamy salad.


The potatoes are diced rather than chopped, and the salad is typically served chilled.

Second, the dressing is a mix of vinegar and mustard, which gives it a slight tanginess.

Amish potato salad also includes bacon, which gives it a delicious smoky flavor, and includes chopped hard-boiled eggs and celery to add crunch and flavor.

This makes for a hearty, yet tasty, side dish.

Finally, Amish potato salad is a popular dish at potlucks and weddings.

What is special about regular potato salad?

Reser's Original Potato Salad, 16 Oz

Check Current Price

What could be more regular than potato salad?

A classic dish that can be found at barbecues and picnics across the country, it’s a staple of summer time eating.

But there are some special things about regular potato salad that make it worth trying out.

First, you can customize it to your own taste by adding your favorite ingredients.

For example, you could try adding bacon, green onions, or diced red peppers.

You could also prepare the salad with a creamy dressing made from sour cream, mayonnaise, and Dijon mustard.

Second, it doesn’t require any complicated steps and it’s always a crowd-pleaser, so you can be sure that everyone will love it.

Lastly, it is affordable and can be made with ingredients that are readily available in most grocery stores.

In my opinion, these factors make regular potato salad a special dish that deserves recognition.

What are the differences between Amish potato salad and regular potato salad?

There are different types of potato salad, but two of the most popular versions are Amish potato salad and regular or classic potato salad.

Although they share some similarities, there are also some key differences between the two versions.

 Amish potato saladRegular potato salad
 Popular in the Amish community.Popular in the United States.
Potatoes choice of servingsThe Amish recipe calls for peeled and boiled potatoes. Regular potato salad usually uses diced or mashed potatoes.
The use of spicesMade with a simple dressing of dill pickles, vinegar, and salt.Regular vinaigrette dressing made with oil, Dijon mustard, and white wine or red wine vinegar.
The type of dressing usedPopular variations include celery, hard-boiled eggs and bacon.Can include a wide variety of ingredients such as mustard, pickles, and celery, and sometimes have green peppers or other vegetables added in.
FlavorTend to be spicier than regular potato salad.Tend to be creamier than Amish salad.

What are the similarities between Amish potato salad and regular potato salad?

Did you know that there are many similarities between the two types of potato salads?

Both salads typically have potatoes, vinegar, sugar and other seasonings.

In terms of dressing, both salads use potatoes as the main ingredient.

Also, these two salads include celery, other vegetables like green peppers, and various herbs and spices.

 Both types of salads are a summer staple, can be enjoyed at a picnic or potluck and can be served cold.

Which one is better?

Product ComparisonReser's Deviled Egg Potato Salad, 16 OzReser's Original Potato Salad, 16 Oz
Product ImageReser's Deviled Egg Potato Salad, 16 OzReser's Original Potato Salad, 16 Oz
Latest PriceCheck Current PriceCheck Current Price

So, which type of potato salad is your favorite?

Do you like potato salad?

Do you like Amish potato salad?

Let us know in the comments section below!

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. When you purchase an item from Amazon through one of my links, I receive a small commission at no added cost. This helps support the site!

Emily W.

Emily Wong is an Asian-American food writer the founder of With nearly 8 years of experience, she has a passion for making cooking accessible to everyone and sharing her personal experiences with food. Emily's vision for is to create a community of food lovers who are passionate about cooking, eating, and sharing their experiences with others. Read my story
Back to top button